SmarterDividends
NIC

Nicolet Bankshares (NIC) Total Return Calculator

$10,000 since May 2013, with and without reinvesting · data through Oct 2026

$10,000 invested in Nicolet Bankshares (NIC) ten years ago, at the end of Oct 2016, was worth $46,032 at the end of Oct 2026 with every dividend reinvested: 16.5% a year, against $41,633 in the S&P 500. Since May 2013, $10,000 became $111,475 reinvested (19.7% a year), or $109,949 taking the dividends as cash, $2,724 of it paid out along the way.

Payouts
Compare with

NIC became

$111,475

S&P 500: $58,110

Return a year

19.7%

S&P 500: 14.0%

Payouts reinvested

$2,780

bought more shares

Worst drop

-39.8%

S&P 500: -23.9%

$10,000, May 2013 to Oct 2026

Payouts reinvested · S&P 500 reinvested

YearNIC total returnPaid outS&P 500
2026 (part)+42.4%$713+11.7%
2025+16.8%$781+17.7%
2024+31.9%$701+24.9%
2023+1.9%$469+26.2%
2022−6.9%$14−18.2%
2021+29.2%$13+28.7%
2020−10.2%$13+18.3%
2019+51.3%$15+31.2%
2018−10.8%$8−4.6%
2017+14.8%$9+21.7%
2016+50.0%$16+12.0%
2015+27.2%$15+1.2%
2014+51.1%$7+13.5%
2013 (part)+3.4%$7+14.8%

"Paid out" is what your holding received that year. Month-end prices; no costs or taxes.

Key facts: NIC total return

Data as of · Source: SmarterDividends data

  • $10,000 invested in Nicolet Bankshares (NIC) at the end of May 2013, with dividends reinvested, was worth $111,475 at the end of Oct 2026: 19.7% a year, against $58,110 (14.0% a year) in the S&P 500.
  • Over the 10 years to Oct 2026, NIC turned $10,000 into $46,032 with dividends reinvested, 16.5% a year.
  • Over the 5 years to Oct 2026, NIC returned 19.9% a year with dividends reinvested (S&P 500: 12.0%).
  • Taking NIC's dividends as cash instead of reinvesting them, the same $10,000 ended at $109,949, including $2,724 of cash received; reinvesting added $1,526.
  • NIC's best calendar year in that time was 2019 (51.3%) and its worst 2018 (-10.8%), with dividends reinvested.
Cite this page

SmarterDividends, "Nicolet Bankshares (NIC) Total Return Calculator," updated Nov 22, 2026, https://smarterdividends.com/stocks/NIC/total-return

NIC total return questions

If I invested $10,000 in NIC 10 years ago, how much would I have?

About $46,032 at the end of Oct 2026, with every dividend reinvested: 16.5% a year. Taking them as cash, you'd have shares worth $44,262 or so plus the cash you received. The same $10,000 in the S&P 500 became $41,633.

What is NIC's total return since May 2013?

1015% in total, or 19.7% a year, through Oct 2026 with dividends reinvested. The share price alone rose 972%.

How much of NIC's return came from dividends?

About 2% of its yearly return since May 2013. Reinvesting them, rather than taking cash, left you $1,526 better off on a $10,000 start.

What was NIC's worst year?

2018, at -10.8% with dividends reinvested (S&P 500: -4.6%). Its deepest fall from a peak, on month-end values, was -39.8%.

How is total return calculated here?

From month-end prices: the adjusted price counts every dividend reinvested in the month it was paid; the plain price doesn't. The S&P 500 is SPY with its dividends reinvested. No trading costs or taxes.