SmarterDividends

Should You Buy Bonds Instead of Dividend Stocks?

November 15, 2026 · 9:57 · 5 views · data through October 30, 2026

We gave three made-up investors $100,000 each on October 31, 2011: Grace in a real T-bill fund (BIL), Marco in SCHD and Sam half and half, and they lived on every payout through October 30, 2026, then did it again from October 2023, when T-bills paid 5.3%. Grace kept her $100,000 and lost a third of what it buys; Marco's paycheck grew every year.

The numbers in this video

13-week T-bill yield vs SCHD's 12-month yield, Oct 30, 2026
3.97% vs 2.95%
Grace's income from T-bills, 2012 to 2021 (ten years)
$4,745
Marco's income from SCHD, 2012 and 2025
$3,176 and $12,318
Total income, Nov 2011 to Oct 2026: Grace, Marco, Sam
$22,760 / $108,843 / $56,493
Grace's $100,044 on Oct 30, 2026, in 2011 dollars
$67,115
Marco's $100,000 in SCHD on Oct 30, 2026, payouts spent
$420,941
Restart Oct 31, 2023, three-year income: Grace vs Marco
$13,091 vs $13,516

$100,000 per investor bought at the close on October 31, 2011: BIL (a T-bill fund, payouts after its fee), SCHD, or half of each reset to 50/50 every December. Every payout, by ex-dividend date, is taken as cash; nothing is reinvested and nothing is sold. Split-adjusted daily closes through October 30, 2026. Today's dollars use CPI-U (October 2026). The second run starts October 31, 2023, SCHD's lowest month-end in over a year, which flatters its balance. The 10-year note is a model and approximate. No taxes or trading costs. Past results from one period, not a forecast. Education only, not investment advice.

Run it with your own numbers

Full transcript

0:00Bonds or dividend stocks?

A Treasury bill pays about 4 percent right now, and SCHD pays about 3, so the safe choice looks obvious. Three investors got $100,000 each. The one who played it safe kept her $100,000 the whole time, and still lost a third of what it buys. By the end you'll know which fits you.

0:23Three investors, one rule

Grace buys Treasury bills through a real T-bill fund, because she hates seeing red. Marco buys SCHD, a fund of American dividend stocks. Sam can't choose, so he splits it half and half and resets it every December. They start on October 31st 2011 and live on the checks, so every payout gets spent.

We made up the three of them. Every price and payout in this video is real, with fund fees taken out, through October 2026. Pick the one you'd be, and put the name in the comments before we run it.

In December 2011 the first checks arrive, and Marco's is $478. Grace's check from the T-bill fund is $4, and for the next four years that would look like a good month.

1:18The zero years

From 2012 through 2015, Grace's fund paid her nothing at all, because short-term rates sat close to zero and the fund's small fee ate the rest. Across the ten years from 2012 to 2021, her income added up to $4,745. That works out to about $40 a month. Even buying the bills herself, with no fund fee, would have paid about $5,696 over those ten years.

Marco's checks went up every year. He got $3,176 in 2012, and by 2021 the same shares paid him $8,824.

In early 2020 the pandemic hit. Between January 23rd and March 23rd that year, Marco's balance fell from $232,471 to $154,902. Grace didn't feel a thing on paper, since her balance stayed right around $100,000.

Her paycheck took the hit instead. Rates dropped back to zero, so her income fell from $2,041 in 2019 to $299 in 2020, and to nothing at all in 2021. Marco's paycheck rose in both of those years, to $7,957 and then $8,824. Sam sat in the middle, with a balance that dipped about 17 percent and income that shrank by about a quarter.

And then 2022 arrived, and this time the people holding bonds got hurt.

3:16The 2022 shock

Prices were climbing fast, and by June 2022, inflation hit 9.1 percent. The Federal Reserve raised rates again and again, and the 13-week Treasury bill went from almost zero at the end of 2021 to about 4.3 percent a year later.

That was rough for anyone holding longer bonds. A fund of 7 to 10 year Treasuries lost 15.1 percent in 2022, counting its interest, while SCHD lost 3.4 percent.

Say Grace had bought a 10-year Treasury note back in 2011 instead. She'd have locked in 2.2 percent, or $2,175 a year. That note came due in October 2021, and the new one she bought paid 1.6 percent, a few months before rates took off. By October 2023, it would have sold for about $78,000.

Grace's T-bills came out of the shock as winners. Her rate reset every few weeks, and her income jumped to $4,911 in 2023 and $5,015 in 2024, the best years she ever had.

By October 2023, a T-bill paid 5.3 percent and SCHD paid 3.8. Anyone starting fresh that month would have picked the bills without thinking twice, so we ran the whole test again from that day.

4:56Start over in 2023

Same three investors and the same $100,000, starting on October 31st, 2023. In the first year, Grace comes out ahead. She collects $5,193, Sam gets $4,780, and Marco gets $4,308.

Then rates started falling, and the bill rate slid from 5.3 percent to 4.4 a year later and to 3.7 the year after that. Grace's income followed it down, to $4,246 in year two and then $3,652 in year three. Marco's went the other way. SCHD's payout per share kept growing from year to year, so his checks grew to $4,558 and then $4,650.

This is the part that surprised us. Over those three years, the safe investor had the paycheck that moved the most, and it moved down. A T-bill only promises its rate until it matures, a few weeks or months from now. After that, you get whatever the market pays.

Add it all up and Marco collected $13,516 in three years, to Grace's $13,091. His balance grew to $157,714, while hers sat at $99,869. One honest note: October 2023 happened to be a cheap month for SCHD, its lowest month-end price in over a year, and that flatters Marco's balance. The paychecks are the fairer test.

There's one more cost in this story, and it never shows up on Grace's statement.

6:58The cost you can't see

Back in the fifteen-year run, prices have risen 49 percent since October 2011. Groceries rose a little less: a cart that cost $100 back then costs $140 today.

Grace still has her $100,000. It buys what $67,115 bought in 2011. She played it safe for fifteen years and lost a third of her buying power without ever seeing a loss on her statement.

Marco's paycheck in 2012 was $3,176, which is $4,661 in today's money. In 2025 he got $12,318, so after inflation his income almost tripled, to about $1,026 a month against Grace's $343. In March 2026, his dividends passed the full $100,000 he started with, and his balance today is $420,941.

Sam landed in between, as you'd expect, with $213,492 in the account and $7,348 of income last year.

That doesn't make Grace wrong. She bought a different thing, and it did its job.

8:29The honest answer

Treasury bills give you a steady balance and a paycheck that swings with interest rates. In this test, that paycheck went from zero to over $5,000 a year, and then it started falling. SCHD gave Marco a balance that fell by a third in two months, and over these fifteen years, a paycheck that grew every year. The split gave Sam about half of each.

If you need the money within a few years, or you can't stand to watch it fall, bills are the right tool. If you'll live on the income for ten years or more, the growing paycheck did far better here, and that holds after inflation. This was one fifteen-year stretch, and a good one for SCHD. Treat it as a lesson, not a promise.

Put in your own amount and see what a dividend stock would pay you at smarterdividends.com, slash calculators, slash dividend calculator. Then hold it up against what a T-bill pays today.

Grace says she sleeps fine. She checked her balance this morning, and it still says $100,000.

More videos